Short · checked 29 September 2026
The custom button shop that Sticker Mule folded into its main store.
Button Frog, a $39-for-50 custom button shop listed from New York, was a Sticker Mule launch from April 2015 that the parent merged into its own site in August 2016.
The Stompstart listing, saved in February 2016, carried the title Button Frogs, though the shop called itself Button Frog throughout. Its pitch was "Custom Buttons Made Easy": free online proofs, free shipping, online ordering and "blazing fast turnaround," with prices from $39 for 50 buttons 2.25 inches across. For now, the listing said, orders were limited to that one size and quantity, though "eventually we will expand to more sizes and quantities." It gave New York as its location and public beta as its status.
Button Frog had launched on Product Hunt on 22 April 2015 as the "fastest and easiest way to order custom buttons online," finishing third for the day with 419 upvotes. It returned there with a Black Friday offer that November.
The listing did not mention Sticker Mule. In August 2016, Sticker Mule announced that "we merged Button Frog into Sticker Mule," so that customers could check out several kinds of product in one cart. Since launching Button Frog in April 2015, the post said, it had held a 4.9 out of 5 review rating, and within a few months it had added three more button sizes and begun accepting orders of 3,000 or more. Buttons on Sticker Mule were "identical to those made by Button Frog," with same-day free proofs, a four-day turnaround and free shipping.
Sticker Mule still sells custom buttons in 1, 1.25, 1.5 and 2.25 inch sizes; when checked in September 2026 the page showed 25,668 reviews averaging 4.5 out of 5. The buttonfrog.com address no longer loads.